The Rules of This Blog

So Rafi asked me in a comment where the rules were, so that he could read and understand them. And although I’ve alluded to them in other posts, I realize I’ve never written them down. So, here they are.

  1. This is the blog of a Jew who practices his Judaism in the Reform manner. Don’t diss Reform Judaism here, or for that matter any form of Judaism. Don’t state or imply that it’s less than any other stream. Discussing the differences between Reform and other streams of Judaism is not dissing. Saying that Reform (or Masorti, or anything not haredi) Judaism isn’t real Judaism is dissing, and I won’t put up with it. The No True Scotsman argument goes in all directions here, too. Orthodox and haredim, despite their behavior sometimes, are also Jews. Got it?
    1. Note:  If you are a Messianic, that’s fine, but you are an evangelical Christian, not a Jew. This may seem to contradict rule 1, but here’s the definition of Judaism in its absolutely most general, most inclusive sense, and the one I use on this blog: God is One. If you follow Jesus, you’re violating that definition. Moving on.
  2. I’m Reform, not uninformed. Don’t assume that I know less than you do about Judaism just because I’m Reform. I may actually know more than you do, as happens frequently with converts.
  3. This is the blog of a Jew who has been through some pretty serious emotional and religious abuse over the years. So step lightly, and be prepared to hear a “no” or “that’s not your business” without taking it personally. I may quarantine comments and email people and say “Change the way you said this, or I’m keeping it blocked,” if I feel generous. If I don’t, I will apply the banhammer.
  4. This is the blog of a Jew who is a gay man. Homophobia, sexism, and transphobia of any flavor are absolutely not allowed here, and will receive an automatic banhammer and blacklisting. There are no second chances on this one.
  5. This blog has been largely for the issues of the convert. Most readers are converts or have converts in their lives. Those issues, therefore, are going to be pretty big on this blog. Details of Talmudic argument, probably not so much.
  6. No trolling, no flamewars. We are discussing some sensitive topics here, and I expect everyone to be an adult about it. Those who cannot be adults will be introduced to the banhammer.
  7. Wil Wheaton’s Rule applies: Don’t be a dick. This is my electronic living room – or Shabbat table, if you like. I expect you to be on your best behavior.

Harsh? Probably. But it’s still the way I run this blog. So if you’re good with these rules? Great! Welcome! Pull up a chair. If you’re not, well, nice seeing you, and the door to other areas of the internet awaits you over there.



Filed under Day-to-Day

4 responses to “The Rules of This Blog

  1. Adam!!!!!!!!You go boy!!!!Love love your rules of your Blog. Being in the process of converting myself (#5), well written.
    This should be in real life too so we don’t “Need” explain why we are converting or the day was can say, “Yes, I am a Jew.”
    Can’t wait to see how you are doing in your final days count down! You are in my prayers.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Dawn Davidson

    Keeping in mind that as you know I am not a Christian (anymore)… I am curious why “following Jesus” violates the God Is One definition. Jesus is an aspect of God, not a separate God. That’s why they call it a monotheistic religion after all. Following Mary I could see as a different God/dess. Not so much Jesus.

    So what’s your line of reasoning there? Curious.

    Congrats on the solid rules of engagement. 🙂


    • The whole “Trinity” thing is a three-god setup masquerading as if it’s all one God. It’s one of the main heresies of Christianity (at least, in Jewish thought). It isn’t monotheistic.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s