Michael Benami Doyle said, in his description of his conversation with the beit din, that there is a prophetic element to being a Jewish convert. I’m experiencing that this week since the Women of the Wall managed to actually read from the Torah and dance with it at the Kotel on Rosh Chodesh Iyar 5775.
One of the jobs of a prophet is to draw attention to what’s wrong and how it can be repaired. Prophets are often disliked when they do this; people don’t like being told that what they’re doing is wrong.
And yet. And yet.
It is still wrong to deny Jewish women the right to pray at the Kotel, as the Haredim continually try to do.
It is still wrong to deny Jewish women access to the Torah at the Kotel, as the Haredim continually do.
It is still wrong to harm anyone who helps Jewish women have access to the Torah at the Kotel, as the Haredim did on Rosh Chodesh Iyar, when they beat Charlie Kalech and Alden Solovy.
Nothing excuses the behavior of the Haredim in these instances. They are fundamentally wrong. They are extremists, and they are damaging the Jewish faith far more than women who pray at the Wall, wear tallitot and tefillin, and read from Torah. They are, to borrow a term from gaming, rules lawyers.
Rules lawyers miss the spirit of the law by adhering so hard to the letter of the law. They never see the bigger picture.They never win in the long term, but they do a lot of damage in the short term. The Haredim are harming themselves and don’t know it. They are harming Judaism and they don’t know it (or perhaps they don’t care).
Regardless of their justification for their actions, I cannot see Adonai supporting the behavior of the Haredim towards the Women of the Wall or the men who helped them. Adonai is not a petty God who needs defense against people who want to worship him. If their God is, well – then the only conclusion I can draw is that their God is not Adonai.
Lo yisa goy el goy cherev, lo yil’madu od milchamah.
Perhaps the Haredim should look at that verse and think about their behavior.
3 responses to “The Rules Lawyers”
Maybe you should start referring to him as Hashem or just God, I have to confess, reading it in a non liturgical setting is kind of weird to me now but hey, who I am to judge you? but at least I can make a suggestion to a fellow.
Sorry, but I’m not going to change how I refer to God.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Perfectly stated, Adam. Right on.
LikeLiked by 1 person